New Zealand Historic Places Trust Pouhere Taonga
 

 


Membership of the Historic Places Trust entitles you to a range of unique benefits including a free subscription to Heritage New Zealand magazine.

 

 

From Heritage New Zealand, Summer 2005

Empty Vessels

by Geraldine Johns

For every historic ship that still exists, there is a story that goes beyond its sailing life. Romance, pluck and perseverence are not soley cofined to the working lives of such vessels: often it is the efforts of a dedicated few that save them from desecration. From New Zealand's collection of historic ships that have lived to see another day, we profile four.

The interior of the Edwin Fox.
Photo: Photo New Zealand / Mike Langford

After a lifetime of hard work: travelling the high seas, surviving storms, collisions and groundings that saw the loss of lives, the Edwin Fox was ignominiously dumped.

So much for her 32 years of international service; the 909-tonne teak sailing ship was declared obsolete and tied up and left for dead at Picton Wharf. It was 1900.The age of steam had supplanted the need for sailing ships. The best that the Edwin Fox - former carrier of convicts, cargo, immigrants and troops across the world - could do was serve as a landing platform and coal hulk

As time would tell, it was the best possible outcome.

"This was her luckiest escape," says John Sullivan, shipmaster of the Edwin Fox. The ship now sits in a purpose-built enclosed dry dock in Picton. It has undergone a painstaking preservation process, costing more than a million dollars, and is recognised by the Historic Places Trust as a Category I historic site. It is regarded as the ninth-oldest identified ship in the world, and is said to be the only one of some 4000 merchant ships built in India that still exist today.

Things would never have worked out that way had the ship stayed in the Northern Hemisphere, says Sullivan."If she was in a major port, she would have been bombed, bulldozed or burned. Instead, she sat, forgotten, on the other side of the world."

And, while serving out her mouldering retirement far from her Calcutta birthplace, perhaps the grand old dame of the sea would have had time to reflect on some of her working achievements. Built by hand in 1853, she was out of date before she even set sail, due to the old design features employed. These can still be seen on the ship in her permanent resting place, adjacent to the Picton Interisland Ferry Terminal.

On her first immigrant voyage from England to New Zealand in 1873, the Edwin Fox hit a particularly bad storm outside the Bay of Biscay. The 15-metre seas took three days to abate. The ship lost not just its mast, but some crew too. Among the dead was the ship's doctor, impaled by a metal rod. And, when the storm subsided, scarlet fever struck, killing four more. Consider this extract from a letter describing conditions on the ship: "A hundred and twenty-two days of misery, anxiety, discomfort and semi-starvation. I hope never again to fall to the lot of an unfortunate emigrant in a slow but sure emigrant ship.

"The Edwin Fox would make three more such journeys in its sailing life. She would also carry cargo between England and the East, convicts to Fremantle and troops to the Crimean War. While most ships of her kind lasted five years, the Edwin Fox served 32.

"She is a remarkable ship," says Sullivan, who used to fish off her when he was a child, and who has been involved with the Edwin Fox Preservation Society since it was re-formed in 1982.

The path to preservation has taken some time. Bought by the first restoration society in 1964 for a shilling, the Edwin Fox was towed to Shakespeare Bay in Queen Charlotte Sound two years later, where it lingered after the society went into recess. Salvation next came knocking when the Edwin Fox Society was formed in 1982. In 1986, the ship was refloated and brought to the Picton Terminal, where it underwent a full archaeological survey. It was found to be 74 per cent original, with 15 per cent of its decks or beams missing. This was the legacy of lying on the beach at Shakespeare Bay, where visitors had stripped it for firewood, and souvenir hunters helped themselves to anything portable. "We were advised it was better to preserve it rather than restore it," says Sullivan.

And that's just what the society has done, aided by a team of volunteers and the liberal use of a chemical called Eusan to halt the deterioration of the ship's timbers.

The project is on-going. A roof covers the ship and a museum sits next to it. It's open to the public all year around, except for Christmas Day and Good Friday - and all sorts of people from all around the world come to visit."I'm bloody sure I had Robert Redford visit 15 years ago, and Burt Reynolds has been too," says Sullivan.

After not falling to the same fate as all others who sailed before her, the Edwin Fox marked its 150th anniversary two years ago. Every preservation effort has been worth it, enthuses Sullivan. "We've got a ship with all this history. As an artefact, it's really unique."

He gets his greatest pride comes "when you look out at the ship on a wild wet day and know you're partly responsible for her being in a dry dock - rather than rotting on a beach".

A handbook, Edwin Fox, Hard-worn Heritage, published to mark its 150th anniversary, spells out the society's intent. "The Edwin Fox Society is dedicated to the task of preserving the ship in such a manner as to ensure that it is available to generations to come as a memorial - not only to those who served in her but also to those brave immigrants who risked their very lives to seek a better environment for themselves and their families in another country half way around the world."

All who board the R. Tucker Thompson must adopt the language of shipping days of yore. It's one of the many traditions that owner/operator Russell Harris observes when he takes passengers out on the tall ship. Some of the habits follow him to shore. "Stand by," he advises when he has to interrupt this telephone interview briefly.

The R Tucker Thompson at sea.
Photo: Courtesy of R. Tucker Thompson

The R. Tucker Thompson is a fastidious heritage link to the sailing days of the past. Although built only 25 years ago, it is recognised as a fine example of a 19th-century small sailing ship. And, because of its youth, it still works for its living. The gaff rigged, square tops'l schooner takes Bay of Islands-based day sailing trips in summer, while in winter it provides sailing training for disadvantaged youth. The plucky little R. Tucker Thompson has sailed the high seas too: its first journey was from England to Australia to mark the Australian bicentennial first fleet
re-enactment. It was part of the Mururoa protest fleet of 1985, and has seen much of the rest of the world as well.

All this from a boat that hardly got beyond being a keel.The story of the R. Tucker Thompson begins, and almost ends, with the migration of the Thompson family from California to Northland in the 1970s. After building a home, R. Tucker Thompson decided to build the "perfect little schooner" - one based on the Halibut schooners of the north-west American coast, says Harris.

But, shortly after the keel was laid at the Thompson family home in Whangarei Heads, R. Tucker died. "There it [the keel] sat in the back yard growing grass for four years," Harris explains.

The ship has a hull of steel, "veneered" with planking that makes it very strong and dry below.

But an approach to Harris by R. Tucker Thompson's son, 19-year-old Todd Thompson, saw the bare bones of the ship shifted to Harris's back yard in Mangawhai Heads in 1982.
And that's when the dream started being realised.

With Todd's encouragement and Harris's experience (he knew how to build and he'd worked on the Bounty replica), the pair set to work.

"We were full of high ideals and limited money," says Harris. Their meticulous attention to detail and observance of past traditions can be seen in the finished product. It's built with demolition wood - much of it from Auckland buildings that were demolished in the early 1980s. Her rig is of varnished Oregon spars.

The deck is sealed with pitch tar, and there's an acre of brass on board. The completed effort eventually cost some $250,000: money obtained - and repaid - through a loan from the Development Finance Corporation, which also did not survive the '80s.

The financial cost did not include the blood, sweat and tears, says Harris. But the creation "is the aftertaste of that maritime era before steam came along and demolished it. We've kept the traditions of these ships alive."

Much of the work is thanks to the tireless efforts of a group of volunteers, many of whom initially knew nothing about building or sailing but became charmed by the venture.

Further links have been discovered since the ship's completion in 1985. She is now said to be of essentially the same configuration and design as a tall ship used by Bishop Pompallier in the 1840s, while travelling around New Zealand and in Wallis and Futuna. Pompallier's craft - another gaff-rigged square tops'l schooner, called the Sancta Maria - proved too costly to maintain and only served for a few years before being sent to Chile for sale.

To board the R. Tucker Thompson is to be taken back immediately in time, says Harris, who describes it as his "living, breathing, sleeping dream." The ship celebrated its 25th anniversary in the Bay of Islands in October. Todd Thompson is no longer involved with the venture, but another generation of Harris children is now involved with her too: daughter Melanie became a skipper and sailed round the world on the ship; son Evan is a Master.

The story of the TSS Earnslaw could so easily have been one that ended with heron the scrapheap. Instead, the steel-hulled, twin-screw steamer still sails the waters of the Waikatipu River, is a designated Historic Place under theNew Zealand Historic Places Act, and will celebrate its 100th anniversary in 2012.

TSS Earmslaw on Lake Wakatipu.
Photo: Photo New Zealand / M Ross

Known locally as "The Grand Lady of the Lakes," the Earnslaw's life came close to being cut short when she passed out of state ownership in 1968. But, thanks to the vision and perseverance of two men, Les Hutchins and Adam Love, she was saved from consignment to a watery grave, says Queenstown historian Neil Clayton.

An expert on local lake steamers and railways, Clayton explains that the Earnslaw was originally built by the Government, partly because of dissatisfaction with the private enterprise operations running steamers on Lake Wakatipu in the early 1900s.

But, in the end, it was private enterprise that saved her, when New Zealand Railways decided to rid itself of the steamship.
Named after Mt Earnslaw, a peak at the head of Lake Wakatipu, the Earnslaw was meant to be the answer to the problems presented by the three privately run steamers before her.

The new harbour steam ferry started her life in Dunedin, where she was built, before being dismantled and taken by rail across country to Kingston, where she was meticulously reconstructed before embarking on her first voyage.

Every quarter-inch steel hull plate of the 48-metre-long vessel had to be numbered for this painstaking purpose.

After her maiden voyage from Kingston to Queenstown in October 1912, the Earnslaw enjoyed a relatively calm life, serving largely as a sheep, cattle and passenger carrier - until progress got in her way.By the early 1960s, roading had supplanted the need for most of its services, with first the Kingston-Queenstown link being built and then the Glenorchy-Queenstown connection.

By the end of that decade, the steamer serviced only sheep stations on the western side of the lake,and the passenger service had almost disappeared, says Neil Clayton.

Enter, then, Stan Shearer, charge officer of the steamer service. "He realised the nature of the service had to change, and he started running a passenger service." The steamer started to operate short lake services and made links with some sheep stations.

"It changed from being cargo-based 365 days of the year to tourism."

New Zealand Railways gave up ownership in 1968; in 1970 Fiordland Travel - under Les Hutchins - took it over. "His vision, to link the Earnslaw into a wider series of passenger and scenic services was very successful, and it still is," says Neil Clayton.

Pivotal to the continued success of the steamship was the role played by Adam Love, an ex-Royal Navy engineer who came to New Zealand as a marine surveyor.

When he set sight on the Earnslaw, he was so entranced, he chose to work on it during his holidays. It was Love who set up a survey and maintenance programme that ensured it kept running and which he continues to do to this day.

He’s one of the many who has vowed to be at the centenary celebrations.

There is, says Neil Clayton, a certain ambience to the running of a steamship that makes people want to come and watch it. “A steamship is almost a living thing.”

He is certain such delights could no longer be enjoyed if it weren’t for the likes of Les Hutchins.

“It was his vision and perseverance that meant it continued to run, and run successfully,” he says.

Just like the other ships that remain to tell us so much about our vanished past, the Earnslaw is with us thanks to the dedicated efforts of a few individuals who didn't know what to give up.

Tim Dare was an Auckland builder in need of a new life and a new job due to a series of worksite injuries. The Echo was an old scow in a bad state of neglect. Her glory days were well past her and she lay abandoned in Picton.

The Echo in the days when she sailed from Wellington to Picton.
Photo: Courtesy of Alexander Turnbull Library

By the time Dare got to meet the Echo, it was a very sorry sight. "She was in a pretty bad state. They were going to bulldoze her," says Dare. Instead, he took over the Echo's operation. Now, both man and boat have been reinvented. The 100-year-old Echo serves as a café and bar in Picton, with Dare and his wife, Denise, as co-owners and operators. They also run a gallery that details the scow's past life.

Kauri-built on the Kaipara Harbour in 1905 - and the first to be built with an engine - the Echo is said to be one of the sturdiest and finest scows ever built in New Zealand. It ran the Wellington-Picton route between 1920 and 1965, interrupted by a spell serving as a supply ship for US forces in 1943 and 1944.

After returning to New Zealand, it continued to run the Cook Strait route until interisland ferry services made it redundant.
It made its last strait crossing in 1965, and seven years later was bought by the Marlborough Cruising Club, which took it to Picton to use as its clubrooms. But, by 1990, the scow had deteriorated to the point it was ready to be sold as scrap. The Dares took it over in 1992 and set about tidying her up. The café and gallery opened two years ago.

It was the age and character of the old scow that drew him to her, says Tim Dare. It was also the fulfilment of a dream - in
a fashion. "I always wanted to run away to sea, but I never made it. Instead, I bought a boat that didn't float."

 

 

 

Places to Visit

Learn more about the historic sites located in and around the regions of New Zealand

 


 

Contact Us | Helpful Tips

© New Zealand Historic Places Trust Pouhere Taonga
Support the Trust by calling
+64 4 472-4341